How To Cook Butter Poached Lobster Tail?

The conventional methods for cooking lobsters in New England include steaming and boiling, but there is another method. The process of cooking lobster meat to the sweetest, most delicate, and butteriest perfection is known as “butter poaching.” Learn how to cook lobster in butter at home.

When making butter poached lobster, the meat is taken out of the lobster and cooked in melted butter at a slow simmer—never a boil. In order to avoid making the meat of the lobster tough, it is cooked slowly and gently using the butter poach method. The ideal way to poach lobster is to prepare everything a la minute, which means making the butter in the same sauce as the lobster. See our advice for cooking frozen lobster tails with the shell on.

You will require:

  • 2-3 tbsp. water
  • 2 sticks of chilled, cubed butter, totaling 1 cup. pieces
  • (6) 3 oz. discarded lobster tails
  • Small saucepan or shallow pot.
  • Quick-read thermometer (optional)


  • Bring 2-3 tablespoons to a boil in a saucepan. to a simmer over medium heat with the water.
  • 1 tablespoon is whisked in. Add another slice of butter once it has melted. Continue to add butter pieces until you have added a total of 1 cup (two sticks). Be careful not to let the butter boil or it may separate. Aim for a butter temperature of between 160 and 175 degrees F. Keep it below 180 degrees Fahrenheit using an instant read thermometer.
  • Add the raw, defrosted tails. Turn tails in the butter mixture after cooking for 6 to 8 minutes. Once more, watch that the butter doesn’t boil and turn the heat down if necessary. Don’t overcook lobster, please. The internal temperature of poached lobster tails should range between 140 and 145 degrees.

What is the ideal method for preparing a lobster tail?

It is not particularly difficult to prepare lobster tails. You can grill, bake, broil, steam, boil, bake, or even smoke lobster tails after purchasing them.

If you’re unsure which method to employ, boiling your lobster tails is your best choice to keep the tails from clinging to the shell.

To begin, select your cooking method from the list below. Continue reading to find out how to store and defrost lobster tails.

How are lobster tails cooked to make them tender?

To prepare lobster tails, cut them in half with a chef’s knife or, for a more appealing presentation, cut the top of the shell down the middle and place the flesh on top. The tails are baked at 425°F (218°C) in a baking dish with a tiny bit of water or wine.

The lobster is tenderly steamed while baking in the oven with water at the bottom of the pan, resembling poaching in texture. This method is excellent for larger lobster tails that require more cooking time. This approach takes roughly 1 to 2 minutes per ounce to fully cook.

How much time should I cook a lobster tail?

The size and length of the lobster tails will affect how long they will take to broil. It is better to boil smaller lobster tails for 7 to 9 minutes. Broiling anything larger than 6 ounces will take 7 to 10 minutes. My meat thermometer is the one thing I never leave the kitchen without while preparing any kind of meat. I watch my meat carefully to make sure I don’t overcook it. To ensure more consistent cooking while broiling a larger lobster tail, move the oven rack down by an additional inch.

Most restaurants cook lobster tails in a certain way.

You can boil, steam, grill, broil, or bake lobster tails. Normally, I like to boil or steam them. When a lobster is finished, its shell becomes red and its meat turns white.

In order to prevent the lobster tails from curling during the boiling process, you must first put a wooden skewer down the length of each tail.

  • 2/3 of a big sauce pan or stock pot should be filled.
  • Heat the saucepan on high until the water is at a rolling boil.
  • the pot with the lobster tail(s) and

the water to boil for:

  • 3.0 ounce tails in 3 minutes.
  • Four ounce tails in four minutes
  • Five ounce tails in five minutes
  • etc
  • After draining the pot, take the lobster tails out.
  • Split the avocado using a sharp knife or kitchen shears.
  • Place the lobster tails on a platter and serve right away with lemon wedge or clarified butter and lemon herb butter!
  • 1 1/2 cups of water should be added to the pot.

Insert a wooden skewer along the length of each lobster tail to prevent curling when grilling lobster after first boiling it.

  • For every quart of water, add about 1 teaspoon of salt to a big sauce pan or stock pot that is about two thirds full.
  • Place the saucepan on a high heat source and wait until the water boils.
  • Cook the tails in the water for around 4 minutes.
  • Once they have slightly cooled, drain the water and put the tails on their backs.
  • Split the tail’s soft top shell lengthwise down the middle using a sharp knife or pair of kitchen shears, leaving the hard shell underneath in tact.
  • Place the tails shell side down into a preheated grill. Brush the tails with melted butter. Squeeze a little lemon juice over the meat of the tails.
  • Grill over medium-high heat for about 7 1/2 minutes, or until the flesh is opaque and firm to the touch (turn the tails over half way through cooking if you wish)
  • Grill the tails off of them.
  • accompanied by hot… lemon wedge, clarified butter, and/or Lemon Herb Butter

Can I cook lobster tails out of the shell?

  • lobster tail preparation
  • Melt butter in a sizable enamel pan over medium heat.
  • Salt, pepper, and garlic to the butter. If necessary, place the lobster’s shell-side up in the butter.
  • Around the lobster tails, place lemon wedges.
  • While cooking, drizzle butter over the lobster tails. Use a turkey baster rather than a spoon to cover the lobster more thoroughly with melted butter.
  • Reduce heat to a simmer if butter begins to bubble.
  • Cook lobster tails with the shell on for 8 to 10 minutes, then turn them over and cook for an additional 2 minutes, or until done.
  • Cook no-shell lobster tails for 8–10 minutes, turning them over few times, until fully done.

How should I prepare frozen lobster tails from Costco?

  • Set the oven to 450 degrees (230 C).
  • The lobster tails should be put in a large baking dish.
  • Pour the remaining sauce over all of the lobster tails after brushing each one with butter and lemon sauce. If you’d like, you can also sprinkle some lemon slices over the tails.
  • Make sure the internal temperature of the lobster tails is between 140 and 160 degrees Fahrenheit and bake them for 12 to 15 minutes.
  • Serve right away.

What is the ideal method for preparing lobster at home?

  • Use a pot that can accommodate the lobsters comfortably, and add water to it until the edges are covered by about two inches of water. (Feel free to put the lobsters immediately to the pot or to a steaming rack.)
  • For every quart of water, put 2 teaspoons of salt in. It would be best if you had sea salt.
  • One at a time, add lobsters to the boiling water as it comes to a full boil. Over a high heat, bring the water to a rolling boil. Put the lobsters in the pot head first, close the lid, bring the water to a boil as soon as you can, and then begin the timer.
  • For the first pound, steam a lobster for 7 minutes each pound. For each additional pound after that, add 3 minutes per pound. For an approximate timeline of cooking, see the graphic below. If the foam begins to bubble over, lower the heat.
  • Utilizing tongs, carefully remove the lobsters from the pot. They are incredibly hot, so use caution. Before cracking, place in a sizable bowl to chill for five minutes.

preparing clams in addition to lobster? Put the lobsters on top of the clams in the netted bag, and then steam both at once.

How are frozen lobster tails poached?

Steaming is quicker than boiling and is perhaps the most common method of preparing lobster tails.

  • Inside a sizable saucepan with a tight-fitting top, put a steamer basket.
  • Fill the pot with water until the edges are covered by about two inches of water.
  • Water is brought to a boil. Place the lobster tails in a single layer in the steamer basket, then secure the lid.
  • Cook the lobster meat until it becomes opaque and white. Make a slit in the bottom tender shell and peek into the flesh to check for doneness.

How are the lobster tails prepared at Outback?

If you’ve ever had the Outback Steakhouse’s Steamed Lobster Tail, you might be startled to learn that it’s supposedly prepared in a microwave-safe pan of water. Although this approach works, it’s not that enticing to observe how it all plays out.

The lobsters are microwaved after being placed in a pan of water. When they are done cooking, melted butter is drizzled over them and paprika is added.

See below:

Anyone who believes that preparing lobster for your family at home can be difficult should take note: It is quite easy and just requires the most basic kitchen equipment. With just a microwave, anyone can open their own Outback Steakhouse.

It sounds awful to microwave lobster, but it gets even worse when you realize the shellfish was kept above the beef. There is a very specific way that meat is stored in restaurant coolers, and this is completely incorrect and may result in food-borne illness. Stupid, Outback. No thanks.

What is the time required to poach a lobster tail?

  • A 10-inch skillet should be heated to medium-low. Add the water, then wait for it to warm up. When adding the butter, whisk it into the water until it melts. The second piece is then whisked in. Garlic, truffle salt, and red pepper flakes are whisked in. The remaining butter will then be whisked in one at a time. Monitor the temperature of the beurre monte with an instant read thermometer. You must maintain it at a temperature of 180°F, but within the range of 160°F and 189°F.
  • Add the lobster tails in a single, tight layer after the butter has completely melted. Turning every 1-2 minutes for a total of around 6 minutes, poach until completely opaque. Boil the linguine (if using) in salted water as directed on the packet at this time.
  • Put the tails on a platter and throw away the bay leaf. Stir in the lemon juice, pepper, and parsley in the pan with the poaching liquid.
  • Add the cooked spaghetti and combine. After adding two lobster tails to each serving bowl, add some pasta to each.