Can You Sear A Beef Tenderloin In Advance? The Full Guide

Cooking a delicious beef tenderloin can be a daunting task, especially if you’re short on time. You may be wondering if it’s possible to sear the meat ahead of time to save some precious minutes.

While it may seem like a good idea, there are some important things to consider before attempting this cooking hack. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of searing beef tenderloin in advance and provide you with some helpful tips to ensure your next meal is a success.

So, grab your apron and let’s get cooking!

Can You Sear A Beef Tenderloin In Advance?

The short answer is no, you should not sear a beef tenderloin in advance. Searing gives the outer layer of your beef a crust, but it does not cook the inside of the meat. If you sear the beef tenderloin the night before and then refrigerate it, there is a high chance that your cut of meat will go bad. The bacteria inside the meat will still be active, and storing it in the refrigerator will only allow it to spread.

It’s important to note that cooking a beef tenderloin is all about balancing time and temperature. If you follow the basic guidelines of time and temperature, you’ll have the perfect beef tenderloin every time. Searing ahead of time may seem like a time-saver, but it’s not worth risking the quality and safety of your meal.

The Benefits Of Searing Beef Tenderloin In Advance

While searing beef tenderloin in advance is not recommended, there are still some benefits to preparing ahead of time. One way to save time is to do all the prep work beforehand, such as gathering ingredients and slicing vegetables. This can help in cooking quickly and efficiently.

Another way to save time is to defrost the meat in advance. This allows you to start cooking right away without having to wait for the meat to thaw. However, it’s important to note that defrosting should be done safely, either in the refrigerator or in cold water.

If you’re worried about not having enough time to cook the beef tenderloin on the day of your event, you can follow the recipe through step one and refrigerate it until you’re ready to finish it off. However, it’s important to note that you should not sear the beef tenderloin ahead of time.

The Risks Of Searing Beef Tenderloin In Advance

Searing beef tenderloin in advance can be tempting, as it seems like a great way to save time and get ahead of the game. However, there are several risks associated with this process. Firstly, searing does not cook the meat all the way through, which means that the inside of the meat is still raw and prone to bacterial growth. Secondly, storing the seared meat in the refrigerator can create a breeding ground for bacteria, as the temperature is not low enough to completely halt bacterial growth.

According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Food Safety and Inspection Service, cooked foods should not be left at room temperature for more than 2 hours (1 hour if the room temperature is above 90 degrees Fahrenheit). This means that if you sear your beef tenderloin in advance, you’ll need to refrigerate it for most of that time and then take it out and cook it just before serving. However, this process can be risky, as the meat may not have been cooked to a high enough temperature to kill off all bacteria.

In addition, reheating beef tenderloin can be tricky. While some chefs suggest wrapping the cooked beef in foil and reheating it in a 350-degree oven for 15 minutes, others caution against reheating expensive cuts of meat as it can affect the texture and flavor. It’s also important to note that reheating beef tenderloin can increase the risk of bacterial growth.

How To Properly Sear Beef Tenderloin In Advance

While it’s not recommended to sear beef tenderloin in advance, there are a few things you can do to prep ahead of time to save yourself some cooking time. One option is to trim the beef tenderloin beforehand. When picking up your meat, it’s best to ask your butcher to trim the beef tenderloin for you. However, if you purchase untrimmed beef loin, you must trim its fat, connective tissue, and silver skin. Skipping this step may result in unevenly cooked meat.

Another option is to prepare the beef tenderloin one day in advance. You can pat dry, salt, and tie your beef whole tenderloin one day in advance. Wrap the prepared meat with plastic and keep it in the fridge overnight. Just be sure to let it rest at room temperature for one hour before putting it in the oven to ensure proper cooking.

If you’re short on time, you can also slice the beef tenderloin into 2 lb. pieces and roast them side-by-side on a wire rack. Any loin 4 lbs. or greater won’t sear properly, so this slicing step will help your meat cook on the stovetop.

When it comes time to sear your beef tenderloin, make sure to use a high-heat oil such as ghee or vegetable oil. Preheat your pan until it’s very hot before adding the beef tenderloin. Sear for 1-2 minutes on each side until a crust forms on the outside of the meat.

Tips For Storing And Reheating Pre-Searing Beef Tenderloin

If you have already seared your beef tenderloin and need to store it for later use, it’s important to follow proper storage and reheating techniques to ensure the meat stays fresh and delicious. Here are some tips for storing and reheating pre-seared beef tenderloin:

1. Store the beef tenderloin whole: After allowing your meat to cool to room temperature, place your beef tenderloin in an airtight freezer bag and refrigerate immediately. It’s best to store the tenderloin whole, so avoid slicing the meat into pieces. Use the meat within 24-hours.

2. Avoid oxidation: When unsaturated fats in the meat mix together with free iron and oxygen, they cause the meat to oxidize, which releases chemical compounds that give your meat a cardboard-like, off flavor. To counter this, store your cooked meat uncut and in an airtight wrapping. Vacuum sealing is the preferred method of storing meat as it allows you to remove most oxygen from the packaging.

3. Reheat properly: Reheat and eat your pre-seared beef tenderloin within 24-hours to avoid inedible meat. The reverse sear method is an excellent way to reheat beef tenderloin without drying it out. Set your oven to 250-degrees Fahrenheit and place your steaks on top of a wire rack inside a baking dish or tray. Cover loosely with aluminum foil and heat until they reach about 100 to 110-degrees Fahrenheit. While your steak warms up in the oven, heat up a skillet with some butter or oil. Once the pan is warmed up and your steaks are out of the oven, sear them on each side for a minute or so until browned.

4. Store properly: To store pre-seared beef tenderloin, cool it down to room temperature first and wrap it with plastic wrap. After that, keep it in the refrigerator in an airtight container. The plastic wrap and airtight container will trap the meat’s moisture and keep it fresh.

5. Avoid using microwave: While using a microwave may seem like a quick option for reheating pre-seared beef tenderloin, it is not recommended as it can dry out the meat quickly. If you must use a microwave, put the beef into a deep microwavable dish, pour gravy or meat juices over the top, cover with plastic wrap, and microwave on medium power for 30-second periods (max power will dry out your steak in no time), turning the steak in between.

By following these tips for storing and reheating pre-seared beef tenderloin, you can enjoy a delicious meal without compromising on quality or safety.

Is Pre-Searing Worth It? A Final Verdict

The debate on whether or not pre-searing is worth it when cooking beef tenderloin is a heated one. Some argue that pre-searing adds flavor and speeds up the browning process, while others argue that it’s not necessary and can even lead to overcooking.

One undisputed benefit of pre-searing is that it sanitizes the outside of the meat by killing any bacteria present on the surface. This is especially important for items with longer cooking times where there may be time for bacterial growth. However, there are other, more effective ways to achieve this, such as dipping the meat into boiling water for a few seconds before bagging it.

Pre-searing can also be a great cooking method when you’re short on time. Starting by pan-searing your steak gives the meat a nice crispy crust, and finishing the cooking process by popping it into the oven gives you better control of its final temperature, reducing the risk of over-cooking.

However, there are also arguments against pre-searing. For example, when you’re trying to minimize finishing time as much as possible – as with sous vide cooking – pre-searing might seem counterproductive. It can lead to overcooking if not done correctly, especially if you sear the steak while it’s hot through, which risks overcooking the meat immediately under the surface.

Ultimately, whether or not pre-searing is worth it depends on your personal preference and cooking style. If done correctly, pre-searing can result in a more evenly cooked and tender steak with a more flavorful surface. However, if not done correctly, it can lead to overcooking and a less enjoyable eating experience. As with any cooking technique, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons and experiment to find what works best for you.